What our guests have said about the Sugar Mill:

Jim & Nancy McEwan
"You all do a great job, as usual everything is very consistent, that’s why we keep coming back. "

David & Robin Hurley, “Your hotel is perfection! We only stayed one night (on my birthday!) before catching a sailboat charter, but we’d like to come back & stay longer next time. We ate dinner at your restaurant & they made my birthday very special. Thank you!...It’s as if you thought of everything. I applaud your hotel, your management, your property & your staff!”

Kathy Johnson, “The stay at the Sugar Mill was the most pleasant travel experience I’ve ever had! We’ll be back.”

Leo Cleek, “ The food was as good as Fodor’s said it was.”

The Cargile Family, “ This is a gem of a place.”

Bob Ross & Jan Alden, “ We had a fantastic & relaxing vacation in a first class hotel on my favorite island. We will be back!!”

Chris & Cynthia Sommers, “What a wonderful & quaint hotel! We feel like we happened upon a little secret on Tortola! Thanks for a memorable stay!”

Kate Borough & Julie Efaw, “ We have traveled extensively and want you to know that this has been our favorite vacation, The Sugar Mill has charm, sophistication, intimacy & a thoughtful approach to customer service. We would like to especially thank all the staff for making us feel so special.”

Dexter & Peter Meath, “We had the best honeymoon that we could have asked for!”

Richard & Elizabeth Hooks, “Food – the best we’ve ever eaten!”

Tony & Mary Dellinger, “ We loved your setting, view, staff & food. A perfect ending to our dream trip to the BVI to celebrate our 35th anniversary, Thanks.”

Karl Luntta, "You've got the beach, you've got a pool, you've got gourmet dining - the best small hotel on the island."

'Best Places to Stay in the Caribbean' "...Best of the Best..."

Caribbean Travel & Life Readership Survey "...Best Restaurant in the Caribbean..."

See more Sugar Mill reviews at TripAdvisor.com and WhereToStay.com